AccessibilitySkip to Top NavigationSkip to Main ContentHome  |  Contact IRS  |  About IRS  |  Site Map  |  Español  |  Help  

11.3.2  Disclosure to Persons with a Material Interest

11.3.2.1  (08-29-2008)
Introduction

  1. IRC §6103(e), Disclosure to Persons Having Material Interest, provides a listing of persons who may generally request and receive returns and return information. IRC §6103(e)(1)-(6) and IRC §6103(e)(10) concern disclosure of "returns." IRC §6103(e)(7) through (e)(9) as well as (e)(10) refer to disclosure of "return information. "

  2. Delegation Order 11-2 indicates the IRS employees who may disclose, or authorize the disclosure of, returns and return information under IRC 6103(e). It also outlines the extent to which this authority may be redelegated.

11.3.2.2  (08-29-2008)
General Rules

  1. Persons described in IRC §6103(e) always have access to the appropriate return as specified in IRC §6103(e)(1) through IRC §6103(e)(6), subject to the limitations in IRC §6103(e)(10) for partnership, trust or Subchapter S returns which are discussed in this IRM. Generally, these persons also have access to return information. A request for a copy of a return must be made in writing.

  2. IRC §6103(e)(7) provides that return information will not be disclosed if the IRS determines that disclosure would seriously impair Federal tax administration. Return information will be denied under this provision only if disclosure will impair an imminent or ongoing tax administration function in some significant way, or have an adverse impact on the IRS's ability to administer the tax laws.

    Example:

    Disclosure of information which would reveal the nature, scope, limit or direction of the IRS's examination investigation, or disclosure of the identity of confidential informants or prospective witnesses.

  3. Some of the provisions of IRC §6103(e) require that the requester demonstrate that he or she has a material interest in the information to be disclosed. A material interest is an important interest and is generally, but not always, financial in nature. However, in the legal sense, the interest needs to be substantial or of consequence.

  4. IRC §6103(e) does not restrict IRS personnel from disclosing tax information to the extent permitted by other provisions of the Internal Revenue Code, such as for investigative purposes (IRC §6103(k)(6)), or the matter of administrative and judicial tax proceedings, (IRC §6103(h)(4)).

  5. It is not necessary in all situations for an individual to be authorized to have access to returns or return information in order to engage in face-to-face or telephone discussions with IRS employees.

    Example:

    There are many situations where employees of corporations may contact the IRS to inquire as to the meaning of a bill, notice or other written communication from the IRS. In the majority of these cases, the communication can be discussed without the need for independent reference to or disclosure of confidential tax information by an IRS employee. IRS employees who handle contacts of this nature should not hesitate to provide the general information the caller requests. Note that IRS employees may accept information from third parties without disclosure being an issue.

  6. Tax treaty information obtained by the IRS from a foreign tax authority may usually be disclosed to the taxpayer to whom it relates on written request in accordance with IRC §6103(e). Disclosure will not be made to the taxpayer if the foreign tax authority providing the information objects to the disclosure or if the IRS deems that disclosure would seriously impair Federal tax administration under IRC §6103(e)(7). See IRM 11.3.25.2(8), Information Received from Foreign Tax Authorities.

  7. Requests under IRC §6103(e) that involve documents related to the Simultaneous Examination Program, or an Industry-wide Exchange of Information or a Spontaneous Exchange of Information, will be handled by the Large and Mid-Size Business Division in accordance with the procedures contained in IRM 11.3.25, Disclosure to Foreign Countries Pursuant to Tax Treaty.

  8. If a Freedom of Information Act request for tax treaty information is received, follow the procedure established in IRM 11.3.13, Freedom of Information Act .

  9. IRM 11.3.22, Disclosure to Federal Officers and Employees for Tax Administration Purposes, discusses the use and disclosure of third party comparable information. Such comparable third party tax information does not lose its individual confidentiality protection simply because it is used to help determine another taxpayer's tax liability.

11.3.2.3  (08-29-2008)
Processing Requests for Returns and Return Information

  1. Requests for copies of tax returns are often made on Form 4506, Request for Copy of Tax Return, and are processed by the campus RAIVS unit designated on the form. Transcripts of accounts may be ordered using Form 4506-T, Request for Transcript of Tax Return. IRS also offers telephonic/electronic access to tax information through programs such as tele-transcripts and "Where's My Refund?"

  2. Other IRS employees may also handle requests for returns and return information.

    Example:

    Requests by taxpayers for information in open collection, examination, and criminal investigation files may be received and processed by those functions. IRM 21.3.6, Forms and Information Requests,contains specific instructions for Customer Service personnel.

  3. Disclosure personnel are responsible for ensuring that requests for returns and return information are processed in accordance with all disclosure rules and regulations. Requests involving complex or unusual circumstances should be coordinated with the appropriate Disclosure personnel. For further information regarding the responsibilities of Disclosure personnel, see IRM 11.3.38, Role and Responsibilities of Disclosure Managers.

  4. IRC §6103(e) requires written requests for copies of tax returns. Although it is preferable that requests for return information also be in writing, the statute permits disclosure of return information without a written request.

    Example:

    After verifying identity, Customer Service personnel may divulge return information to taxpayers concerning their refund checks.

  5. Information furnished to the IRS by third parties (e.g., informants) may be returned to the third party upon request in most instances, provided the material has remained in its original state. This is not considered a disclosure under IRC §6103(b)(8), since nothing is being made " known" to the providing party. However, if it has become integrated with other return information or if the information has been used and this use of the information by the IRS is in any way reflected on the document, it may be returned only as provided by IRC §6103. Additionally, the document or information must be withheld from the third party if the return of such document or information would impair or interfere with tax administration.

11.3.2.3.1  (08-29-2008)
Requirements for Written Requests

  1. Written requests for returns and return information should include:

    1. The name, address and identifying number of the taxpayer

    2. A description of the information requested, including type of tax and taxable period and

    3. Sufficient evidence to establish that the requester is entitled to receive the requested information.

  2. IRS personnel processing requests for returns and return information must be reasonably satisfied that the requester is who he or she claims to be.

  3. Identification is not normally required for written requests. If there are doubts about a person's identity, IRS employees must request additional identity information or offer to mail the requested information to the taxpayer's name and address of record.

11.3.2.3.2  (08-29-2008)
Requirements for Verbal or Electronic Requests

  1. When responding to verbal or electronic inquiries from taxpayers, no return information may be disclosed until IRS personnel have asked sufficient questions and received adequate information to make certain that the person making the inquiry is the taxpayer, the taxpayer's authorized representative, or some other person authorized under IRC §6103(e). In the case of electronic access, the system will ask the necessary questions. See IRM 11.3.2.4 below, for more specific guidance as to who can have access to various types of returns and return information.

    Note:

    Authentication requirements vary based on the IRS program, the identity of the requester, and the information sought. The appropriate IRM or office procedures will be followed. After the taxpayer is authenticated, it is still necessary to determine whether the requested information may be disclosed to that person in accordance with IRC §6103.

  2. The following information may help to verify the requester’s identity:

    1. Taxpayer's name as it appears on the tax return

    2. Taxpayer's address as it appears on the tax return or as modified on IRS records

    3. Taxpayer's social security number (SSN) or employer identification number (EIN)

    4. In the case of refund inquiry, the type of tax (e.g., individual, corporate, estate, excise), the approximate amount of expected refund (unless computed by IRS) and the place of filing

    5. For a matter involving an individual income tax return, the date of birth and/or filing status, and/or

    6. Other unique identifier issued by the IRS

  3. An in-person requester must be asked to present a driver's license or other acceptable proof of identity (e.g., other photo ID or 2 non-photo documents/cards). A telephone requester should be given the option of calling back, making a written request, or having the information mailed to the address of record if there are doubts about the caller's identity. Information should not be mailed to a taxpayer, even at his or her address of record, if the requester is clearly not the taxpayer or other authorized IRC §6103 recipient.

    Note:

    Notwithstanding the guidance above, functions may establish internal policies and implement procedures allowing tax information to be sent to the address of record based upon a request from a third party who does not represent the taxpayer or who does not hold a tax information authorization. These decisions are based upon the function’s assessment of the risks and vulnerabilities concerning the possibility that an unauthorized individual could gain access to such information and their willingness to accept the level of risk involved.

  4. Responses to verbal inquiries must be limited to the disclosure of return information.

  5. Copies of tax returns cannot be disclosed upon verbal request. Requests for copies of returns must be made in writing.

11.3.2.4  (08-29-2008)
Persons Who May Have Access to Returns and Return Information Pursuant to IRC §6103(e)

  1. This subsection covers the persons to whom returns and return information may be disclosed upon proper request and the circumstances under which the disclosures can take place.

11.3.2.4.1  (08-29-2008)
Individuals

  1. Returns and Return Information of an individual filing Form 1040 may be disclosed to:

    1. That individual

    2. If property transferred by that individual to a trust is sold or exchanged in a transaction described in IRC §644, (repealed for sales and exchanges made after 8/5/97), the trustee or trustees, jointly or separately, of such trust to the extent necessary to ascertain any amount of tax imposed upon the trust by IRC §644

    3. The spouse of that individual if the individual and spouse have signified their consent to consider a gift reported on the return as made one-half by the individual and one-half by the spouse pursuant to the provisions of IRC §2513, or

    4. The child of that individual (or the child's legal representative) to the extent necessary to comply with the provisions of IRC §1(g) involving tax on unearned income of minor children. See IRM 11.3.2.4.10.

      Note:

      Community property rules alone do not allow a spouse to access the single return or return information of the other spouse pursuant to IRC §6103(e). However, this does not preclude disclosure, where appropriate, under other provisions of IRC §6103. See IRC §6103(h)(4), IRC §6103(k)(6), IRM 11.3.21, Investigative Disclosure, and IRM 11.3.22 ,Disclosure to Federal Officers and Employees for Tax Administration.

  2. Returns and return information of individuals filing income tax returns jointly may be disclosed to either of the individuals with respect to whom the return is filed.

    Example:

    If a wife signs a joint income tax return for her husband, the husband may make a written request and receive the return since it was filed with respect to him.

    Reminder:

    This only applies to the joint return itself, including attachments.

    1. Information documents posted to an individual's Information Return Master File account are individual, not joint, information returns. The fact that information on a joint return is derived from such individual returns does not convert the individual character of the data. If such individual returns are filed with the joint return and as long as the disclosure is made from the joint return filing, then joint return disclosure rules apply. This is not meant to preclude disclosures, where appropriate, under other provisions of IRC §6103. See IRC §6103(h)(4), IRC §6103(k)(6), and IRM sections 11.3.21 and 11.3.22.

      Reminder:

      Even if a jointly filed return liability is converted to a separate spousal assessment (e.g., under Innocent Spouse or Offer-In-Compromise provisions), IRC §6103(e)(1)(B) still applies to return information developed relative to the new separate assessment. However, in these situations the non-assessed spouse would ordinarily be entitled to only IRC §6103(e)(8) type information due to the application of IRC §6103(e)(7).

      Reminder:

      The Form 4506, Request for Copy of Tax Return, procedures for requesting Form W-2 are for the individual W-2 copies and do not involve information taken from the income tax return.

  3. IRC §6103(e)(8) provides for disclosures pertaining to deficiencies assessed with respect to persons who have filed jointly but are no longer married or no longer reside in the same household. IRC §6103(e)(8) provides that certain limited collection information regarding one spouse must be disclosed to the other spouse relative to tax deficiencies with respect to a jointly filed return. It does not apply to deficiencies which may not be collected by reason of IRC §6502.

  4. Disclosures requested pursuant to IRC §6103(e)(8) will be made only upon written request. Requests will be signed by the taxpayer or his/her duly authorized attorney-in-fact. The IRC §6103(e)(8) process will be used only if the taxpayer has specifically requested the IRC §6103(e)(8) authority. Otherwise, the request will be processed under the authority of IRC §6103(e)(7). Disclosures of collection information, pursuant to either IRC §6103(e)(7) or (e)(8), relative to joint returns where the spouses are divorced or separated should be limited as described in (7) and (8) below.

  5. Any employee having delegated authority to make disclosures pursuant to IRC §6103(e) as detailed in Delegation Order 11-2 may make disclosures pursuant to IRC §6103(e)(8).

  6. Disclosures made pursuant to IRC §6103(e)(8) must be limited to the specific tax period associated with the requester's joint deficiency.

  7. Information that must be disclosed upon receipt of a proper written request from a spouse who has been assessed the joint tax will include:

    1. Whether the IRS has attempted to collect the deficiency from the other spouse

    2. The amount collected, if any, and the current collection status (e.g., notice, TDA, installment agreement, suspended), and

    3. If suspended, the reason for suspension (e.g., unable to locate, hardship, etc.)

  8. Information which will not be disclosed includes:

    1. The other spouse's location or telephone number

    2. Any information about the other spouse’s employment, income, or assets, and/or

    3. The income level at which a currently not collectible account will be reactivated

  9. If a requester insists on receiving information about the spouse which is prohibited as outlined above, advise him or her to file a Freedom of Information Act request in order to receive the associated appeal rights, or to contact the appropriate Disclosure Office for guidance.

  10. The IRS has the authority to develop procedures controlling the frequency with which any requester can make requests pursuant to IRC §6103(e)(8). GLD has determined that only 1 request per 6 month (calendar) period will be allowed.

  11. Requests for returns must be in writing.

11.3.2.4.1.1  (08-29-2008)
Identity Theft and Access to Information Returns

  1. Situations may arise when an individual’s Social Security Number (SSN) or other personal information may be compromised, resulting in a report of income being earned by that individual when in reality it was not.

  2. Information returns such as Form W-2 and Form 1099 reflecting earned or unearned income that are extracted and placed on the Information Return database can be disclosed to the individual who has been assigned the SSN listed on the information return though the income was presumably earned by another individual. This is allowed because the IRS would hold the person assigned the SSN responsible for the payment of any tax on the reported income.

    Note:

    Once it has been determined that the income contained in the information return(s) was not earned by the person to whom the SSN is assigned, such that there is no tax consequence to that person as a result of the income reported on this return(s), no further disclosures of information related to this return may be made to that person.

  3. If an individual states that income information reported as earned by another individual is actually his or her income and wants access to the information, do not release any information unless the requesting individual is able to show he or she was employed by or received income from the business entity filing the W-2 or Form 1099. This is best evidenced by a pay stub or other documentation from the employer, the filing of a FTC Identity Theft Affidavit, a copy of a police report relating to an identity theft issue, or other acceptable documentation.

  4. If the requester establishes that he or she earned the income, only the information regarding the particular information return or returns at issue may be released.

  5. Other information about handling allegations of identity theft and advising affected taxpayers can be found at:
    http://irweb.irs.gov/AboutIRS/bu/pipds/pip/itim/idtheft/default.aspx

11.3.2.4.2  (08-29-2008)
Partnerships

  1. Returns and return information of a partnership may be disclosed to any person who was a member of the partnership during any part of the period covered by the return. Both general and limited partners are entitled to request and receive partnership returns and return information. On December 20, 2007, IRC §6103(e)(10) was enacted, limiting the disclosure of certain information attached to partnership returns. The information to be disclosed cannot include any supporting schedule, attachment, or list of a person other than the individual making the request for access. A requesting partner can no longer receive any Forms K-1 or other attachments that include identifying information of other partners or other individuals. He or she can receive only Forms K-1 that pertain to his or her interest in the partnership. See Exhibit 11.3.2-2 which contains detailed guidance about information that can be released to individuals seeking access to partnership returns, including schedules that must be restricted or sanitized prior to release.

    Note:

    Any information in transcript form or in administrative files that may include other third party information extracted from or attached to Form 1065 must also be evaluated in accordance with IRC §6103(e)(10).

  2. Before disclosing tax information concerning a partnership, verify that the person who has asked for the information was a partner during the requested tax year or has been authorized by a partner to receive Federal tax information. If the person requests partnership tax information for the year 2007, for example, that person must establish that he or she was a partner at some time during 2007. To determine whether a requester was a member of the partnership for the year requested, verify that a schedule K-1 was filed for the requester. Partners may also file a power of attorney authorizing other individuals to receive partnership information or represent the partnership. The individual holding the power of attorney cannot have any greater access to the return or return information of the partnership than the individual granting the power of attorney. All rules in IRC §6103(e)(10) relating to the restrictions of the disclosure of 3rd party tax information apply to the power of attorney as well. The IRS employee should verify the person's status as a partner by following the identification procedures and techniques outlined in IRM 21.1.3.2.3, Required Taxpayer Authentication, and IRM 21.1.3.2.4, Additional Taxpayer Authentication . The disclosure of information concerning employment tax matters relating to partnerships follows the same rules. If a question concerns an employment tax matter and no partnership return has yet been filed, the IRS must still verify that the individual is a partner by analyzing whatever information the individual may be able to provide. It is up to the requestor to provide sufficient identifying information for the IRS to verify that he or she is a partner or is otherwise authorized to receive tax information about the partnership. As always, the decision concerning whether or not to disclose the requested information will depend on a reasonable analysis of the best information provided by the requester and from IDRS or other available information.

    Note:

    A Form 941, Employer's Quarterly Federal Tax Return submitted by a partnership must be signed by a responsible and duly authorized member or officer having knowledge of its affairs. A Form 941 may also be signed by a duly authorized agent of the taxpayer if a valid power of attorney has been filed (See Treasury Regulations §31.6061-1 and §31.6011(a)(7)). Because the Internal Revenue Code restricts disclosure of partnership returns and return information to partners and does not make any exception for Forms 941 filed by partnerships, the IRS may not disclose any tax information to an officer of the partnership (who is not a partner) even though that officer may have the authority to sign and may in fact have signed the Form 941. The partnership may submit a power of attorney permitting the officer, as a full time employee, to act on its behalf or may authorize disclosure of the partnership's Federal return and return information to the officer.

  3. Requests for returns must be made in writing.

11.3.2.4.3  (08-29-2008)
Corporations

  1. Any corporate officer authorized by the corporation in accordance with applicable state law to legally bind the corporation. The authority to bind means the ability to execute agreements that are binding and legally enforceable against the corporation under state law:

    1. "A corporate officer authorized to legally bind the corporation " includes, but is not limited to, the president or other chief executive officer of the corporation

    2. Generally, a written statement by the officer, on corporate letterhead stationery, to the effect that he/she has authority to legally bind the corporation is sufficient to permit disclosure. If there is a question about the requester's authority to receive the returns or return information, mail the information to the corporate address of record

    3. For telephone requests, ask sufficient questions to establish the identity and position of the caller

      Example:

      Ask a corporate officer who is not the president of a corporation if he/she can legally bind the corporation. If there is a question whether the requester is authorized to receive the requested return information, mail it to the corporation at the corporate address of record.

  2. Any person designated by resolution of the corporate board of directors or other similar governing body.

  3. Any officer or employee of the corporation, upon submitting a written request which is signed by a principal officer and attested to by the secretary or any other officer.

  4. To the extent that (1)-(3) above do not apply, any officer or employee who signed the return on behalf of the corporation under forms or regulations prescribed by the Secretary or signed a corporate income tax return under IRC §6062, and who is still employed by the corporation in the same capacity with the same authority. See IRC §6061 and its regulations. Processing information relating solely to the filing of the return signed by that person may be disclosed as long as that person continues to act on behalf of the corporation in the same capacity (with the same authority) as when he/she signed the corporate return. IRC §6103(k)(6) disclosures may also be made when appropriate, if the IRS personnel need to obtain information from the corporation.

  5. Any bona fide shareholder of record owning one percent or more of the outstanding stock of the corporation, upon submitting documentation which reasonably demonstrates such ownership. Such shareholders may have access to returns and return information for all years. However, they have no access rights when they are no longer shareholders. See IRM 11.3.2.5.1 for additional information and guidelines about requests from one percent shareholders.

  6. If a corporation was an electing small business corporation under subchapter S of chapter 1, any person who was a shareholder during any part of the period covered by such return during which an S corporation election was in effect. All types of shareholders, regardless of the percentage of shares held, may receive subchapter S returns and return information. A return or return information cannot be disclosed to a person who was not a shareholder during some part of the year for which the return in question was filed. Nor may a shareholder receive returns or return information for any period during which the election was not in effect.

    Note:

    Not all Schedules K-1 attached to the Sub-Chapter S return ( Form 1120S) can be provided in response to a written request for access. Only the Schedule K-1 for the person making the request can be released. Any other schedules or attachments containing other 3rd party information must be sanitized or withheld per IRC §6103(e)(10). See Exhibit 11.3.2-3 for more details about what can be released and what needs to be edited or sanitized prior to release. This restriction also applies to any information extracted from Schedules K-1 found in various transcripts or administrative files.

  7. If the corporation has been dissolved, any person authorized by applicable State law to act for the corporation, or any person whom the IRS finds to have a material interest that will be affected by information contained in the return or return information. Material interest is an important interest and is generally, but not always, financial in nature.

11.3.2.4.4  (05-24-2005)
Subsidiary of a Corporation

  1. To the extent that a subsidiary filed a separate return, the disclosure of the subsidiary's return and return information is governed by the same rules as those set out in IRM 11.3.2 .4.3, above.

  2. If a corporation has filed a consolidated return which includes the return of the subsidiary, the entire return and return information is the return or return information of the subsidiary. Disclosures are governed by the rules set out in IRM 11.3.2.4.3, above.

  3. Whether or not consolidated returns have been filed, persons authorized to act for the parent corporation may request and receive returns and return information of the subsidiary. A parent corporation is one having over 50% ownership of the subsidiary.

  4. Requests for returns must be made in writing.

11.3.2.4.5  (08-29-2008)
Government Agencies

  1. Returns and return information of a Federal, State or local government agency may be disclosed to any person legally authorized to act for such agency. Generally, verification that the requester is a government official, such as a director of taxation or personnel, will be sufficient.

  2. Tribal council members and other officials of Federally recognized Indian tribes and Alaskan Native villages are also entitled to receive returns and return information. Rev. Proc. 2002-64 lists currently recognized tribal and native village governments. Non-federally recognized tribes or native organizations are treated like any other non-governmental organization.

  3. Requests for returns must be made in writing on appropriate government letterhead.

11.3.2.4.6  (08-29-2008)
Tax Exempt Organizations

  1. Returns and return information of a tax exempt organization that are not publicly available under IRC §6104 may be disclosed to any person legally authorized to act for the organization. A requester’s right of access is based upon the structure of the organization. If the organization is a corporation, the rules for access to a corporate return or return information must be followed. If the entity is a trust or other type of entity, those rules must be followed.

  2. Requests for returns must be made in writing on appropriate organizational letterhead.

11.3.2.4.7  (08-29-2008)
Estates

  1. The administrator, executor, or trustee of an estate may receive returns and return information of the estate.

  2. Any heir at law, next of kin, or beneficiary who establishes a material interest which will be affected by the return or return information may also receive returns and return information. A material interest is an important interest and is generally, but not always, financial in nature.

    Example:

    Submission of a copy of a will by a beneficiary who is described in the will as entitled to " x" percent of the decedent’s gross estate, together with a statement that the decedent's return is needed to assist the beneficiary in determining whether he/she has received a proper share of the estate, would generally be sufficient to permit disclosure. The merits of an action, such as a law suit brought by a beneficiary, will generally, but not always, have no bearing on the material interest determination.

  3. The requester must furnish satisfactory evidence that he/she is an administrator, executor, trustee, heir at law, or next of kin under applicable state law, or is named as a beneficiary in the decedent's will. Generally, written evidence such as a copy of the will, proof of relationship, or letters testamentary will be furnished to show satisfactory proof of entitlement.

  4. See IRM 11.3.3.3, Distinction between Disclosure to Designees and the Conference and Practice Requirements, regarding representatives for estates.

  5. Requests for returns must be made in writing.

11.3.2.4.8  (08-29-2008)
Trusts

  1. The trustee or trustees, jointly or separately, may receive returns and return information of a trust.

  2. Any beneficiary of a trust may receive returns and return information of the trust, but only if the beneficiary shows a material interest which will be affected by the tax information. A material interest is an important interest and is generally, but not always, financial in nature.

    Note:

    Releases of Forms 1041 trust returns must comply with the requirements of IRC §6103(e)(10) . Generally all Forms K-1 cannot be released in response to a request for access to a trust tax return. Provide only a copy of the Form K-1 pertaining to the person making the request to that individual or his/her legal representative. Do not release any other schedule or attachment to the return that contains other 3rd party identifying information. See Exhibit 11.3.2-1 for more details about the various forms and schedules and how they should be edited or withheld prior to release. This restriction also applies to any information extracted from those schedules that may be found in various transcripts or administrative files.

  3. The requester must furnish satisfactory evidence that he/she is a trustee or beneficiary of the trust. A person with a reversionary interest in a trust will be considered a "beneficiary" or "trustee" only if he or she is accorded such status by the law of the state where the trust was established.

    Example:

    If the beneficiary of the trust submits a copy of the trust document together with a statement that the requested information is needed to help him/her determine whether to bring action against the trustees for breach of their fiduciary duty, that information would generally be sufficient to permit disclosure. The merits of an action or a contemplated action will usually not have a bearing on the material interest determination.

  4. Tax information may be disclosed to a person identified on Form 56, Notice Concerning Fiduciary Relationship because that person is acting in a fiduciary capacity for the trust, but only if he/she can establish a material interest in the tax information being requested. The filing of Form 56 is not by itself sufficient to substantiate a material interest. Be sure the information presented establishes a valid material interest. Discuss any questions with your Disclosure office.

  5. Trustees often use a bank's Trust Department to manage or control the assets of a trust. Employees assigned to these departments are acting in a fiduciary capacity. Form 56 should be filed identifying the person who is acting in a fiduciary relationship. A "person" in this case can be an individually named employee or all employees in a bank’s trust department, depending on the wording of Form 56.

  6. If there is doubt that the person seeking tax information is who he or she claims to be, ask for a copy of Form 56 to be sure the person is individually listed or that the Form 56 references the "bank Trust Department, " and the person is actually a Trust Department employee.

    Note:

    IRM 3.13.2.19.1 indicates that a processed Form 56 is evidenced by the input of TC 098 on the account along with the trustee’s name and address. This may be researched on the IDRS entity module. To the extent that the validity of the Form 56 can be established by using IDRS research, do not ask the requester to provide other verification without good reason.

  7. If there are indications that the person seeking tax information is not individually named or a Trust Department employee, then do not disclose any tax information to that person. Alternatively, you could send the information in a sealed envelope to the Trust’s address of record or the address of the person/department listed on Form 56, if the requester first establishes a material interest.

  8. A person seeking tax information can have access to the information of a Trust limited to just processing issues if he or she signed the Form 1041, is an employee of the bank’s Trust Department and is employed in the same capacity he or she held when the return was signed. In order to obtain access to tax information not related to processing issues, the person seeking tax information must show a "material interest" as discussed above.

  9. Requests for returns must be made in writing.

11.3.2.4.9  (08-29-2008)
Incompetents

  1. If an individual is legally incompetent, a return or return information that would be available to him or her ( See IRM 11.3.2.4.1 through 11.3.2.4.8, above, or IRM 11.3.2.4.10, below), can be disclosed to the committee, trustee or guardian of his or her estate.

  2. Situations where an individual may be legally incompetent include those where the individual is a minor, or is senile, disabled, insane, or otherwise incapable of fully administering his or her own affairs.

  3. Generally, we look to appropriate state law for the definition of a guardian, trustee or committee of the estate of an incompetent.

  4. Court appointed guardians, trustees, and committees, as well as fiduciaries, administrators and executors, may also have access to returns and return information on behalf of incompetents, if they produce copies of the appropriate documents establishing their rights and authority.

  5. To the extent necessary, Disclosure personnel should coordinate with Area Counsel to identify pertinent portions of state statutes, common law and Federal law to help determine entitlement to returns and return information.

  6. When handling requests for returns and return information of incompetents, use discretion so as not to impose an undue burden on the requester. If there is a significant question about the requester's entitlement, IRS employees may offer to mail the return information to the taxpayer's name and address of record.

  7. Requests for returns must be made in writing.

11.3.2.4.10  (08-29-2008)
Minors

  1. Returns and return information of a minor may be disclosed to the minor.

  2. Returns and return information of a minor may be disclosed to the signer of the return. Generally, this is a parent of the child but the child may sign the return. Rev. Rul. 82–206, 1982-2 C.B. 356, advises that if the child cannot prepare and file his/her own tax return, the parent should do so on behalf of the child, using the following language to sign the return: " By (signature) Parent (or guardian) for minor child." The revenue ruling is derived from IRC §6012 and the regulations. Treasury Regulation 1.6012-1(a)(4) requires the guardian or other person charged with the care of the minor's person or property to make and file the return on behalf of the child if the child did not make and file the return. Inherent in this subsection is the authority to discuss the return and resulting tax liability, including any necessary collection activities, with a parent who signed the return. A parent who signed the return can also designate the non-signing parent to receive the return or return information of the child if a consent to disclose is properly submitted pursuant to IRC §6103(c) .

  3. Returns and return information of a minor may be disclosed to the minor's parents, if the minor's return reflects earned income. Pursuant to IRC §6201(c), parents are liable for their minor child's unpaid taxes to the extent they are based on compensation for the child's services. If the return reflects earned income of the minor, the return may be disclosed to the parent pursuant to IRC §6103(e)(1)(A)(i), and the return information pertaining thereto may be disclosed to the parent pursuant to IRC §6103(e)(7). In situations where IRC §6201(c) applies, information about the minor's return may be disclosed to the parent even if the parent has not signed the return.

    Note:

    If the parent has signed the minor child's return, the disclosure may be made if an appropriate request is received from the parent, without considering whether IRC §6201(c) applies.

  4. IRC §6103(e)(2) provides for disclosure to the committee, trustee, or guardian of an incompetent's estate. If, under state law, the parent is the legal custodian of the minor's estate, all issues concerning the minor's tax liability (whether it relates to earned or unearned income) may be discussed with the parent. The IRS must look to state law for guidance concerning the effects of guardianship, custody, and non-custody of the minor on the disclosure of the minor's return and return information. To the extent necessary, Disclosure personnel will coordinate with Area Counsel to identify pertinent portions of state statutes, common law and Federal law applicable to determining entitlement to returns and return information.

  5. See IRM 11.3.3, Disclosure to Designees and Practitioners, for information on how a minor could authorize a parent to access the minor's tax information, or a parent signing a minor's return on the minor's behalf could authorize a representative such as the non-signing parent to access the minor's tax information.

  6. Requests for returns must be made in writing.

11.3.2.4.11  (08-29-2008)
Deceased Individuals

  1. The administrator, executor, or trustee of an estate may receive the returns and return information of the deceased individual. Often, an estate is already settled at the time a request for returns and return information is made, and thus an administrator, executor or trustee of the estate will no longer exist. In these circumstances, a person seeking disclosure will often need to consult state law to determine how appointment of an administrator, executor or trustee of the estate may be accomplished.

  2. Any heir at law, next of kin, beneficiary under the will, or a donee (recipient) of property may receive the returns and return information of a deceased individual. Such person must have a material interest that will be affected by the requested information. A material interest is an important interest and is generally, but not always, financial in nature.

  3. The requester must furnish satisfactory evidence that he/she is an administrator, executor, trustee, heir at law, next of kin, beneficiary under the decedent's will, or a donee (recipient) of property. Acceptable documentation includes, but is not limited to: birth and/or death certificates, letters testamentary, a will, or other court document.

  4. If the requester is an heir at law, next of kin, beneficiary, or donee, he/she must show a material interest which will be affected by the requested information. In some states, however, simply establishing a material interest may not be adequate.

    Example:

    A person alleging to be the common law wife of a deceased individual requests exemption information from the separate return filed by her alleged spouse in order to show that her illegitimate child is entitled to receive Social Security benefits. In jurisdictions where a common law spouse and illegitimate child may not inherit from his or her alleged spouse or parent (in the absence of their inclusion in the will or subsequent legitimizing), the spouse and child are precluded from obtaining returns and return information. Even though they each have a material interest affected by the information, they do not qualify as an heir at law, next of kin, beneficiary, or donee under state law, and thus are not entitled to receive returns and return information of the deceased individual. However, a surviving relative of the deceased who also has a material interest in the decedent's returns may be able to secure copies and provide them to the child claiming illegitimate status. Access to deceased alleged parents' returns by illegitimate children will generally depend on state law. In such circumstances, research is needed to ensure all disclosures are proper.

  5. Requests for returns must be made in writing.

11.3.2.4.12  (08-29-2008)
Bankruptcies

  1. Bankruptcies are governed by Title 11 of the U.S. Code. Information about the types of bankruptcy cases as they relate to the material interest issues discussed below is found in Chapters 7 and 11 of Title 11 (U.S. Code).

  2. IRC §6103(e)(4) & (5) set forth several interrelated rules that provide the basic legal framework for addressing material interest disclosure issues in a bankruptcy context. Disclosures for tax administration purposes are discussed in IRM 11.3.22, Disclosure to Federal Officers and Employees for Tax Administration.

  3. The IRS may always disclose the debtor-taxpayer's returns and return information to the debtor-taxpayer, and to any other person with the debtor-taxpayer's written consent. For detailed instructions involving disclosures to a debtor's attorney. See IRM 11.3.3.1.6, Disclosure to an Attorney-in-Fact.

  4. Disclosures cannot be made to the U.S. Trustee in a tax administration matter pursuant to IRC 6103(e). Disclosures may be made to the U.S. Trustee, the trustee, or other creditors in accordance with IRC §6103(h) if the bankruptcy case pertains to tax administration. See IRM 11.3.22. The U.S. Trustee, when acting as "policeman" for the Bankruptcy Court to ensure compliance with the tax laws (particularly, staying current with tax deposits), may receive tax information consistent with IRC §6103(h)(4)(A). The U.S. Trustee's efforts to ensure tax compliance qualify as a tax administration activity under IRC §6103(b)(4)(B). The bankruptcy process incorporating the statutory and judicially imposed requirements relating to tax collection is a Federal judicial proceeding pertaining to tax administration within the meaning of IRC §6103(h)(4).

  5. Disclosure rules distinguish between trustees in Chapter 7 and 11 cases where the debtor is an individual, and other trustees in bankruptcy, e.g., corporate Chapter 11 cases. In individual Chapter 7 or 11 cases, IRC §1398 applies and a return for the estate of the debtor is filed by the trustee (thus creating a separate taxable entity) in addition to the return filed by the debtor. See (2) above regarding disclosure to the debtor-taxpayer.

  6. In an individual's Chapter 7 or 11 case, any return of the debtor for the taxable year when the case commenced or any preceding taxable year shall be available to the trustee. A bankruptcy case commences with the filing of a petition in court. The trustee may also obtain return information relating to the returns available to the trustee, if disclosure of the return information would not seriously impair tax administration.

  7. In an involuntary case, no disclosure of a debtor's return will be made to the trustee until an order for relief has been entered by the court having jurisdiction, unless the court finds that disclosure is appropriate for purposes of determining whether an order for relief should be entered.

  8. Returns and return information of the bankrupt estate filed by the trustee as described in (4) above are available to the trustee. See IRM 11.3.2.4.7 for a description of trustee rules. The debtor may also obtain the returns and return information of the bankruptcy estate.

  9. Different rules apply for disclosure to a trustee (if one has been appointed) in cases other than individual Chapter 7 and 11 cases. These are cases where IRC §1398 does not apply and no separate taxable entity has been created. In such cases, the debtor's return and return information for current and prior years may be disclosed to the trustee. The trustee must furnish satisfactory evidence that he/she is trustee. The trustee in his/her fiduciary capacity, must also establish a material interest which will be affected by the requested information.

    Example:

    A trustee for a corporate taxpayer in a bankruptcy case wants to know the amount of the taxpayer's pending refund in order to propose a distribution among the taxpayer's creditors. In this case, the trustee has a material interest and may obtain the requested information.

  10. In Chapter 13 bankruptcies, trustees are not entitled to tax information under IRC §6103(e)(4) as they have no responsibility for the debtor's tax returns. For disclosures to be allowed, the bankruptcy would need to be a judicial proceeding pertaining to tax administration (see (3) above), or the debtor must provide a consent for disclosure under IRC §6103(c).

  11. Bank examiners are not trustees. To receive tax information, they must have a valid IRC §6103(c) consent from the taxpayer or the disclosure must satisfy IRC §6103(h)(4) provisions when the bankruptcy proceeding becomes a tax administration proceeding.

  12. Additional information pertaining to bankruptcy disclosures, including detailed examples, can be found in Document 9225 , Bankruptcy Disclosure Handbook.

  13. Requests for returns must be made in writing.

11.3.2.4.13  (08-29-2008)
Trust Fund Recovery Penalties

  1. IRC §6103(e)(9) provides for certain disclosures to persons who have been assessed the trust fund recovery penalty (TFRP) pursuant to IRC §6672. IRC §6103(e)(9) allows one responsible person to obtain certain limited information about other persons assessed the penalty for the same underlying tax.

  2. Disclosures pursuant to IRC §6103(e)(9) may be made only upon receipt of a written request. The request must be signed by a person actually assessed the TFRP or his/her duly authorized attorney-in-fact.

    Note:

    Be careful when processing IRC §6103(e)(9) requests as they involve tax information pertaining to individuals other than the requester. While the attorney-in-fact provisions of IRC §6103(e)(6) apply, the provisions of IRC §6103(c) do not, as another party's tax information is involved.

  3. Any employee delegated the authority to make disclosures pursuant to IRC §6103(e) by Delegation Order 11-2, may make disclosures pursuant to IRC §6103(e)(9).

  4. Disclosure personnel will advise employees making such disclosures to be certain that disclosures are limited to the specific tax periods associated with the requester's TFRP. Not all responsible officers subject to the penalty are assessed for the same periods. See the general rules as outlined in IRM 11.3.40, Disclosures Involving Trust Fund Recovery Penalty Assessments.

  5. Disclosures made pursuant to IRC §6103(e)(9) shall also be made in written form upon receipt of a proper written request from a person who has been assessed the penalty or their duly authorized attorney-in-fact. The disclosure will be limited to the specific tax period associated with the requester's TFRP and must include:

    1. Names of the other individuals assessed the same penalty